Despite the gloomy economic conditions which prevailed
during the 2009 financial year, Mvelaphanda Group
succeeded in growing its business, albeit marginally.
This in itself is a great achievement given the decline
in the GDP growth rate into negative territory with
consumption expenditure continuing to contract as
households remain financially distressed. Business
entities, particularly in mining and manufacturing,
which represents a large portion of our clientele, are
experiencing financial pressures as a result of the
financial turmoil.
Despite the adverse economic climate, the Group
succeeded in growing its revenue by 6% and operating
profit by 4%. The year under review saw the Group
starting to generate positive cash flows from its strategic
investments, and the Group managed to slow the pace
of cash outflows during the last six months of the
financial year.
The Group has also succeeded in reducing its
weighted average cost of capital to 12% as well
as improving its debt-equity ratio to 44,0% from
58,6% the previous year. The return on investments
amounted to only 2,1%, mainly as a result of the
upward fair value adjustment on major investments.
This was partly offset by a reversal of deferred tax
assets in respect of the downward fair value
adjustment of certain investments. The margin represents a huge improvement from the negative
returns of 2008. Return on operating assets
increased to 15,1% for the 2009 financial year from
10,4% the previous year.
Financial reporting controls
Working capital and cash flow management are regularly
monitored as is evidenced by the low increase of only
R9 million in working capital for the year under review
compared to R120 million the previous year. This is
commendable when measured against revenue growth
of R207 million and
R77 million in the 2009 and 2008
financial years respectively.
Group companies are conservatively geared with all
investment funding being approved by the Mvelaphanda
Group board. Where possible, investments continued to
be financed on a ringfenced basis, with the relevant
financier only having recourse to the specific investment
which they have financed, and not the Group as a
whole. In certain instances the non-recourse financing
is contained in special-purpose vehicles (which are not
classified as subsidiaries of Mvelaphanda Group).
Similarly the liabilities are not included on the Group’s
balance sheet. Details of the off-balance sheet liabilities
are provided later in this report. No new investments
were made during the year under review. The financing
of the 2008 investment in Avusa was finalised during the
2009 financial year.
The Group’s internal audit department continued to play
an important part in the overall system of financial
control and ensures that internal controls and accounting
standards are maintained in line with the Group’s
requirements.
Financial performance
The Group derives income from its operating and
investment activities which are more fully described in
the operations and investment reports respectively.
Revenue of R3 746 million was 6% ahead of the prior
year’s revenue of R3 539 million with profit from
operations increasing by 4% to R256 million from
R247 million the previous year. Earnings before interest,
tax, depreciation and amortisation (“EBITDA”) were
R374 million compared to R394 million in the prior year,
a decrease of 6%.
Net interest paid for the year amounted to R145 million
compared to net interest received of
R57 million in 2008.
The decrease was mainly as a result of lower cash
balances for the year under review together with the
introduction of the debt incurred to part fund the
acquisition of the investment in Avusa and the fullyear
effect of the debt relating to the investment in
Vox Telecom acquired the previous year.
The gross interest earned on cash balances yielded an
effective 9,1% return per annum, whilst the average cost
of debt in 2009 increased to 13,4% from 11,6% in 2008. Dividend income for the year under
review amounted to R50 million compared to
R11 million in 2008.
The fair value adjustments and profit and loss, excluding
dividend income, from investments amounted to a net
gain of R315 million for the 2009 financial year against
a loss of R1 631 million for the previous year. Included in
the net gain is a R37 million fair loss relating to the fair
value adjustment on the interest rate swap as a result of
the forward prime curve (used to predict three-month
JIBAR) predicting lower interest rates. The Group values
its portfolio of investments in accordance with
International Financial Reporting Standards (“IFRS”),
specifically IAS 39, Financial instruments measurement
and recognition.
A loss from associates in the amount of R34 million was
recorded for the current year compared to a loss of
R526 million the previous year. The share of loss from
associates of R34 million is net of an impairment of
R116 million mainly in respect of the Group’s interest
in Avusa in which Mvelaphanda Group holds a
25,5% interest.
The amortised cost on the 124 425 055 redeemable
option-holding shares (“BEE shares”), issued during the
2007 financial year by the Group, relating to employees,
has been recognised in the income statement in
accordance with AC 503, Accounting for black economic
empowerment (BEE) transactions at R16 million for the
current financial year.
Tax of R250 million was charged to the income
statement of which R28 million resulted from the
payment of secondary tax on companies in respect of
ordinary and preference share dividends paid during the
year and R168 million in a deferred tax charge relating
mainly to the net fair value gain on strategic investments.
Of the aforementioned R168 million, R74 million relates
to the reversal of the deferred tax provisions mentioned
above in the introductory paragraph.
Ordinary dividends totalling R118 million were paid
during the year under review in respect of a final
dividend declared for the 2008 financial year, whilst
a dividend of R30 million was paid to preference
shareholders during the year. The 54,7 million
convertible perpetual cumulative preference shares
are convertible at the instance of the holder into
1,08 ordinary shares for each preference share held
between 4 November 2009 and 4 November 2010, after
which date the preference shares are redeemable either
at the instance of Mvelaphanda Group or remain as
perpetual preference shares. The further reduction in the
conversion price of the preference shares to R9,30 per
share from R10,00 per share (2008: R9,53) was
published on SENS (4 December 2008) in line with the
terms of the offering circular issued to Mvelaphanda
Group’s shareholders dated 4 November 2005.
The weighted average net number of ordinary shares in
issue decreased by 2,4% to 407 million ordinary shares
at 30 June 2009 from 417 million ordinary shares at
30 June 2008 as a result of a full-year effect in respect
of share buy-backs during the previous financial year.
No share buy-backs were undertaken in the current
financial year. The 465 million diluted weighted average
net number of ordinary shares in issue is calculated on
the basis that all the preference shares will be converted
to ordinary shares on 4 November 2009.
Taking the above into account, earnings per share
amounted to 21,9 cents compared to a loss per share of
368,0 cents in the previous year. The headline earnings
per share amounted to 49,9 cents compared to headline
loss per share of 362,6 cents in the previous year.
Cash flow
The Group generated R363 million cash from its
operating activities for the year under review compared
to R271 million the previous year, whilst R52 million cash
was generated from investment activities for the 2009
financial year, an increase of R41 million from the
previous financial year. The Group’s cash position,
however, reduced by R400 million to R470 million at
30 June 2009, mainly as a result of the cash portion
of the Avusa acquisition as well as increased debt
repayments during the financial year.
Cash earnings per ordinary share generated from
operations, which is a critical guideline for determining
the annual dividend paid to ordinary shareholders,
decreased to 21 cents in 2009 from
39 cents the
previous year. |